Open Standard · MIT License

DECIDERS.md

An open standard for defining which decisions require an authorized human in AI-assisted systems.

AI proposes. Humans decide.

AGENTS.md
Defines how agents act
+
DECIDERS.md
Defines where human authority begins

What is DECIDERS.md?

DECIDERS.md is a Markdown file placed at the root of a repository that declares the human decision-rights policy for AI-assisted systems. It specifies which decisions must remain with an authorized human, which actions an AI may take autonomously, and who holds each decision right.

Think of it as the governance complement to AGENTS.md. Where AGENTS.md tells agents how to work, DECIDERS.md tells the organization where human authority begins.

DECIDERS.md is not:

≠ AGENTS.md — instructions for agents
≠ SOUL.md — agent identity
≠ ETHICS.md — agent conscience
≠ FAILSAFE.md — technical shutdowns

Three decision tiers

DECIDERS.md classifies every AI action into one of three tiers based on who may authorize it.

Tier 1 — Autonomous

Routine, low-risk, reversible actions the AI may take without approval. Running tests, formatting code, generating documentation.

Tier 2 — Propose & Approve

Consequential actions the AI may propose but cannot execute until a designated human decider approves. Merging to main, modifying infrastructure, sending external communications.

Tier 3 — Human Only

Actions that must be initiated and executed by a human. Production deployments, access control changes, financial approvals, compliance configuration.


Quick start

Create a DECIDERS.md file at the root of your repository.

DECIDERS.md
# DECIDERS.md

## Governance Statement

This project uses AI agents for development and operations.
All consequential decisions require approval from an authorized
human decider. Routine, low-risk, reversible actions may be
performed autonomously within the boundaries defined below.

## Decision Categories

### Tier 1 — Autonomous
- Running test suites and linters
- Creating and updating draft pull requests
- Generating documentation from code
- Formatting and refactoring within established patterns

### Tier 2 — Propose and Approve
- Merging to main              Decider: Tech Lead
- Modifying CI/CD config        Decider: DevOps Lead
- Updating dependencies         Decider: Tech Lead
- External notifications        Decider: Product Owner

### Tier 3 — Human Only
- Production deployments        Owner: VP Engineering
- Access control changes        Owner: Security Lead
- Financial approvals           Owner: CFO

## Escalation Mechanics

Tier 2 requests posted to #approvals with @mention.
Timeout: 4 hours business, 12 hours outside.
Fallback: system holds until a human responds.

## Delegation Rules

Deciders may delegate to a named backup for a defined period.
Tier 3 decisions may not be delegated to AI systems.

Where it fits

The AI convention ecosystem has organized into distinct layers. DECIDERS.md fills the governance layer that no other convention addresses.

How agents act
AGENTS.md
Where human authority begins
DECIDERS.md
Who agents are
SOUL.md
What agents believe
ETHICS.md
What agents can do
SKILL.md
When agents break
FAILSAFE.md

How to use DECIDERS.md

Add DECIDERS.md

Create a DECIDERS.md file at the root of your repository, alongside your AGENTS.md.

Define your tiers

Classify actions into autonomous, propose-and-approve, and human-only categories based on risk and reversibility.

Name your deciders

Assign each consequential decision to a specific, accountable human. Not a team, not a role, not an algorithm.

Set escalation rules

Define how approval requests are routed, what timeouts apply, and what the system does when a decider is unreachable.


FAQ

Does this mean humans approve every action?

No. Tier 1 actions are explicitly autonomous. DECIDERS.md defines the boundary between autonomous and human-authorized actions. It doesn't require human approval for everything.

Are there required fields?

No. DECIDERS.md is standard Markdown. The three-tier structure and decider registry are recommended but not enforced. Adapt it to your governance needs.

How does this relate to AGENTS.md?

They're complementary. AGENTS.md tells agents how to work in your project. DECIDERS.md tells the organization which decisions require human authority. One is operational. The other is governance.

Can I update it later?

Absolutely. Treat DECIDERS.md as a living governance document. Review it when team structure changes, when AI capabilities expand, or at regular governance intervals.

Who created this?

DECIDERS.md is an open standard published under the MIT license, offered as a complement to AGENTS.md. Its escalation mechanics were informed by publicly documented human-in-the-loop safety primitives — the THROTTLE, ESCALATE, and KILLSWITCH.md patterns. Contributions and critique are welcome on GitHub.